Gentlemen,

I did not review your papers.  But of course, now that you've told me of
them my interest is piqued and I would love to have preprints, whenever you
might have them available.

I can say that Herb Tobias mentioned that he was asked if he could review H
papers for you, but I vaguely recall that it was one of you who asked.  I
am absolutely certain that he had not received anything at the time that
conversation took place - probably early summer.

Best regards,

Tom Brenna
Cornell University
Savage Hall
Ithaca, NY 14853
fax ((607)255-1033





At 02:33 PM 8/31/00 -0400, you wrote:
>     Did you review our papers?  We're searching for an unknown reviewer,
>from whom we hope to obtain more complete comments.  Here's the story: we
>submitted two manuscripts about hydrogen isotopic data processing and H3+
>correction to a journal which shall remain nameless.  The manuscripts have
>now been accepted for publication, pending revision.  One obviously
>knowledgeable reviewer marked up the manuscripts quite helpfully.  For some
>reason, the journal forwarded only the marked manuscripts, even though the
>annotations suggest that there are probably separate pages with more
>detailed comments.  When we asked about this, the journal reported that they
>had no separate pages and that the reviewer's email no longer worked, nor
>did they have any other way to contact him (?).  So we'll try this approach:
>If you recently reviewed our two manuscripts, please accept our thanks and
>check to see whether you might still have a copy of your comments. You may
>send the comments directly to us (see below), or by way of the journal's
>editorial office.
>
>regards,
>
>Alex Sessions
>John Hayes
>
>
>________________________________
>Alex Sessions
>Mail Stop 4
>Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute
>Woods Hole, MA 02346
>
>office: Fye 116
>phone: (508) 289-2570
>email: [log in to unmask] <mailto:[log in to unmask]>