https://www.ucsf.edu/magazine/covid-body
We Thought It Was Just a Respiratory Virus
We were wrong.
By Ariel Bleicher and Katherine Conrad UCSF
Magazine Summer 2020 Illustration: Anna & Elena Balbusso
In late January, when hospitals in the United
States confirmed the presence of the novel
coronavirus, health workers knew to watch for
precisely three symptoms: fever, cough, and
shortness of breath. But as the number of
infections climbed, the symptom list began to
grow. Some patients lost their sense of smell and
taste. Some had nausea or diarrhea. Some had
arrhythmias or even heart attacks. Some had
damaged kidneys or livers. Some had headaches,
blood clots, rashes, swelling, or strokes. Many had no symptoms at all.
By June, clinicians were swapping journal papers,
news stories, and tweets describing more than
three dozen ways that COVID-19, the disease the
coronavirus causes, appears to manifest itself.
Now researchers at UC San Francisco and around
the world have begun taking a closer look at this
dizzying array of symptoms to get at the
disease’s root causes. They are learning from
people inside the hospital and out; people on the
brink of death and only mildly sick; people newly
exposed and recovered; people young and old,
Black, brown, and white. And they are beginning
to piece together the story of a virus unlike any known before.
How infection sets in
Viruses lead a curious purgatorial existence of
being neither fully alive nor dead. Enveloped in
a protein cloak, a virus consists almost entirely
of genetic material – DNA or RNA, the blueprints
for all of life. But it can’t reproduce on its
own. To survive, it must break into a cell and
co-opt the cell’s gene-copying machinery.
The novel coronavirus, an RNA virus named
SARS-CoV-2, has become notorious for its skill at
breaking and entering human cells. Its tools of
choice are the protein spikes protruding from its
surface – a feature that distinguishes all
coronaviruses. The spikes of SARS-CoV-2 are the
crème de la crème: By the luck of the
evolutionary draw, they are able to easily grab
hold of protein gates on human cells known as
ACE2 receptors and, like jackknives, pry these gates open.
Illustration of a coronavirus symbol.
Spikes on the virus’s surface act like jackknives
to break and enter human cells.
“You can think of an ACE2 receptor like a docking
site,” says
<https://fattahilab.ucsf.edu/lab-members>Faranak
Fattahi, PhD, a
<https://fellows.ucsf.edu/current-fellows>UCSF
Sandler Fellow. When the coronavirus pandemic hit
San Francisco, Fattahi repurposed her laboratory
to study this key receptor, which normally plays
a role in regulating blood pressure. “When the
virus lands on it,” she says, “it initiates a
molecular process that brings the virus inside the cell.”
If you’re exposed to SARS-CoV-2 – say, from a
cough or sneeze – the virus will likely first
encounter ACE2 receptors on cells in your nose or
throat. But these receptors also populate your
heart, gut, and other organs. Fattahi’s team has
found evidence suggesting that male sex hormones
such as testosterone may increase the number of
ACE2 receptors that cells produce, which could
help explain
<https://www.ucsf.edu/magazine/frontliner-fattahi>why
SARS-CoV-2 seems to wreak greater havoc on men
than on women and why kids rarely get sick. “The
fewer ACE2 receptors, the less risk of infection
– that’s the idea,” she says, adding that this
hypothesis for the disease’s gender gap is only one of several.
Once inside a few initial host cells, the virus
sets them to work churning out copies of itself.
Within hours, thousands of new virus particles
begin bursting forth, ready to infect more cells.
Although SARS-CoV-2 is less deadly than the
original SARS virus, which emerged in 2002, it
replicates more rapidly. Also unlike SARS, which
primarily infects the lungs, SARS-CoV-2
replicates throughout the airway, including in
the nose and throat, making it highly contagious – like the common cold.
Illustration of the inside of a head, with coronavirus cells th
SARS-CoV-2 replicates throughout the airway,
making it highly contagious, like the common cold.
However, infection with SARS-CoV-2 usually
doesn’t feel like a cold. Fewer than 20% of
infected people who eventually show up at a
hospital report having had a sore throat or runny
nose. During the first few days of being
infected, you’re more likely to have a fever, dry
cough or, peculiarly, lose your sense of smell or taste.
Most likely, though, you won’t feel sick at all.
When UCSF researchers tested people for
SARS-CoV-2 in San Francisco’s Mission District,
<https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2020/05/417356/initial-results-mission-district-covid-19-testing-announced>53%
of those infected never had any symptoms. “That’s
much higher than expected,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/monica.gandhi>Monica
Gandhi, MD, MPH, a UCSF professor of medicine
with expertise in HIV. Surveys of outbreaks in
nursing homes and prisons show similar or even
higher numbers. “If we did a mass testing
campaign on 300 million Americans right now, I
think the rate of asymptomatic infection would be
somewhere between 50% and 80% of cases,” Gandhi
says. Millions of people may be spreading the
virus without knowing it, she points out, making
asymptomatic transmission the
<https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMe2009758>Achilles’
heel of efforts to control the pandemic – and
highlighting the
<https://academic.oup.com/ofid/article/7/4/ofaa131/5820544>importance
of universal masking.
“The majority of people who have COVID-19 are out
in the community, and they are either
asymptomatic or only mildly ill,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/sulggi.lee>Sulggi Lee,
MD, PhD, a UCSF assistant professor of medicine.
When the coronavirus pandemic hit San Francisco
in early March, Lee conceived a study to
investigate why. She scrambled to assemble a team
and
<https://pbbr.ucsf.edu/awards/awardees>procure
funding and equipment. She borrowed a colleague’s
<https://twitter.com/ucsfdelivercare?lang=en>mobile
clinic – a van outfitted with an exam table and a
phlebotomy chair – so that her team could drive
around the city, collecting samples from infected
people. Lee hopes data from the study, called
CHIRP (COVID-19 Host Immune Response
Pathogenesis), will show how people’s immune
systems respond as SARS-CoV-2 starts to gain a foothold in their bodies.
“A lot is riding on that initial response,” she
says. If Lee and her collaborators can figure out
the biological processes that allow some infected
people to stay relatively well, they can perhaps
use that knowledge to prevent others from falling severely ill.
Battling in the lungs
True to its name, SARS-CoV-2 (which stands for
severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2)
is first and foremost a bad respiratory virus. If
your immune system doesn’t defeat it at its
landing site in your nose or throat, it will
advance down your windpipe, infiltrating the
cells lining your lungs’ branching air tubes. At
the tubes’ ends, tiny air sacs called alveoli
pass oxygen to your blood. As the virus
multiplies, the alveoli may fill with fluid,
shutting down this critical gas exchange. Your
blood-oxygen level may drop and, typically about
six days into an infection, you may start feeling short of breath.
What causes this mayhem? “Some of it is
definitely caused by the virus itself,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/michael.matthay>Michael
Matthay, MD, a UCSF professor of medicine who has
studied acute respiratory diseases for more than
30 years. Inevitably, a fast-replicating virus
will kill or injure many of the lung cells it
infects; the more cells it infects, the more ruin it will leave in its wake.
Illustration of a coronavirus symbol.
The virus’s fatality rate seems to be roughly 10 times that of the flu.
But SARS-CoV-2 doesn’t appear to be a savage
destroyer of cells. Although it’s too early to
know for sure, the virus’s fatality rate seems to
be roughly 10 times that of the flu. “You would
think that’s because it’s just a killing
machine,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/max.krummel>Max
Krummel, PhD, UCSF’s Smith Professor of
Experimental Pathology and chair of the Bakar
ImmunoX initiative. So far, however, the science suggests otherwise.
“One of the weirder things about this new
coronavirus is it doesn’t seem to be incredibly
cytopathic, by which we mean cell-killing,”
Krummel says. “Flu is really cytopathic; if you
add it to human cells in a petri dish, the cells
burst within 18 hours.” But when UCSF researchers
subjected human cells to SARS-CoV-2, many of the
infected cells never perished. “It’s pretty
compelling data that maybe we’re not dealing with
a hugely aggressive virus,” Krummel says.
The bigger provocation, he suspects, may be your
own immune system. Like any pathogen, SARS-CoV-2
will trigger an immune attack within minutes of
entering your body. This counterstrike is
extraordinarily complex, involving many tactics,
cells, and molecules. In a
<https://www.comet-study.org/>UCSF study called
COMET (COVID-19 Multi-Phenotyping for Effective
Therapies), Krummel and other scientists have
been observing this immune warfare in more than
30 people admitted to UCSF hospitals with
COVID-19 and other respiratory infections. “What
we’re doing is looking at patients’ blood, their
genes, and the secretions from their noses and
lungs, and we’re asking, ‘What’s your army? What’s your response strategy?’”
An early analysis of COMET data, Krummel says,
suggests that the immune systems of many
hospitalized patients mobilize differently – and
more aggressively – against SARS-CoV-2 than
against influenza viruses, which cause the flu.
Their lungs are ravaged, these data suggest, not
by the virus alone but by the detritus of an
immunological battle gone awry. This rogue immune
response could explain why, around day 11 of a
COVID-19 infection, patients often develop a
severe pneumonia known as acute respiratory distress syndrome, or ARDS.
Ultimately, COMET seeks to find COVID-19
therapies that can rein in an overeager immune
system in order to prevent or treat ARDS. But
that feat won’t be easy, says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/carolyn.calfee>Carolyn
Calfee, MD, MAS ’09, an ARDS expert, UCSF
professor of medicine, and co-leader of the
study. Too much or the wrong kind of
intervention, she explains, could cripple a
person’s immune system to the point where it
can’t clear an infection. “It’s a fine line
between therapeutic and deleterious,” Calfee
says. “We’re trying to find that balance.”
Typically, people who die from COVID-19 ARDS die
around day 19. Reported rates of mortality have
varied widely, with the highest rates being where
the pandemic has hit hardest, overwhelming
hospital resources and staff. At UCSF hospitals –
likely due to the city’s early shelter-in-place
orders, which prevented an initial surge of
COVID-19 cases – so far only 10 of 85 critically ill patients have died.
“The good news is that we’ve been doing clinical
trials of best-care practices for ARDS since
1998,” Matthay says. Thanks to
<https://petalnet.org/general-public>research by
him and others, for example, clinicians have long
known which ventilator settings result in the
fewest deaths and how to flip patients onto their
stomachs – a technique known as proning – to best
help them breathe. If public health measures can
keep hospital admissions low so that frontline
providers can make good use of the skills and
knowledge they already have, we may find that we
have less to fear from SARS-CoV-2 than we thought.
On the other hand, the virus behaves in ways that are still mysterious.
[]
GO TO WEBSITE FOR INTERACTIVE GRAPHIC
Text upper left: From Head to “COVID Toes”
underlined. Text below underline: People with
COVID-19 exhibit from none to many of these
symptoms. Some symptoms (such as fever, cough,
and loss of smell) are common, while others (such
as sore throat, pink eye, and stroke) are rare.
Middle of page: Illustration of human body. From
the top: Brain with one plus sign that opens to
text reading: Headaches, brain fog, dizziness,
delirium, stroke, and another plus sign that
opens to text reading: Pink eye. Throat area with
plus sign that opens to text reading: Loss of
smell or taste, runny nose, sneezing, sore
throat. Heart with plus sign that opens to box
reading: Arrhythmia, weakened cardiac muscle,
heart attack. Lower left lung with plus sign that
opens to text reading: Cough, shortness of
breath, lung injury. Kidney with plus sign that
opens to text reading: Kidney injury, elevated
liver enzymes. Intestines with plus sign that
opens to text reading: Nausea, stomachache,
vomiting, diarrhea. Upper thigh with plus sign
that opens to text reading: Fever, fatigue,
muscle aches, inflammation, blood clots, vascular
injury. Toe with with plus sign that opens to
text reading: Skin rash, numbness or swelling in
feet or hands. Bottom of illustration: rectangle
filled with faded-back coronaviruses and text at
far right reading: illustration Stephanie Koch.
Left of body illustration: small illustration of
coronavirus. Top and right of illustration: small illustration of coronavirus.
Concept credit: Jennifer Babik, MD, PhD
Heart failure
In April, Susan Parson, MD, a Bay Area medical
examiner, made a startling discovery. For nearly
two months, officials had believed that the first
people in the U.S. to die from COVID-19 had died
of respiratory failure in Washington state in
late February. At the time, the U.S. Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention limited testing to
people who had respiratory symptoms and had
recently traveled to China or otherwise been
exposed to the virus. Those restrictions, however, turned out to be misguided.
As a medical examiner for California’s Santa
Clara County, Parson had done a routine autopsy
on a 57-year-old woman named Patricia Dowd, who
had died suddenly at home on February 6. In
Dowd’s tissues, Parson found the cause of her
death: SARS-CoV-2. But the virus hadn’t wrecked
Dowd’s lungs. In fact, she had only mild
pneumonia. Instead, SARS-CoV-2 had ruptured her heart.
Meanwhile, epidemiologists began learning that
preexisting heart disease and related conditions
put people at greater risk of suffering and dying
from COVID-19. “We’re finding that many patients
who have more severe forms of the illness are
obese, they are diabetic, they are hypertensive,”
says cardiologist
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/nisha.parikh>Nisha
Parikh, MD, a UCSF associate professor who
specializes in population health research. Such
risk factors, she says, are unusual. “They’re not
ones that really stood out in prior epidemics.”
Clinicians, too, were seeing surprising numbers
of COVID-19 patients develop heart problems –
muscle weakness, inflammation, arrhythmias, even
heart attacks. “We’re not used to respiratory
viruses having such dire consequences on the
heart in such apparently high numbers,” says
cardiologist
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/gregory.marcus>Gregory
Marcus, MD, MAS ’08, UCSF’s Endowed Professor of
Atrial Fibrillation Research. Many patients whose
hearts acted up also had failing lungs. But
others had no other symptoms or, like Dowd, only mild ones.
Since March, Marcus has co-led one of the largest
community surveys to better understand the spread
of SARS-CoV-2 and its myriad effects. The study,
dubbed COVID-19 Citizen Science, has so far
enrolled more than 27,000 people; anyone with a
smartphone <https://eureka.app.link/covid19>can
participate. Marcus plans to also start
collecting data from wearable devices, including
Fitbits and Zio patches, which wirelessly monitor
heart rhythms. “There may be large numbers of
people who are suffering from cardiovascular
effects of COVID-19 in the absence of other
symptoms,” Marcus says. “I’m worried we’re missing those cases.”
It stands to reason that SARS-CoV-2 affects the
heart. After all, heart cells are flush with ACE2
receptors, the virus’s vital port of entry. And,
indeed, laboratory experiments suggest that the
virus can enter and replicate in cultured human
heart cells, says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/bruce.conklin>Bruce
Conklin, MD, a professor of medicine and an
expert in heart-disease genetics at UCSF and the Gladstone Institutes.
But Conklin doesn’t think SARS-CoV-2 necessarily
kills heart cells outright. Rather, in the
process of copying itself, the virus steals
pieces of the genetic instructions that tell the
heart cells how to do their job. “It’s hauling
away and hijacking stuff that’s necessary for the
heart to beat,” he says. He is currently testing
this hypothesis using human heart cells grown in
cup-sized vessels in the lab of
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/todd.mcdevitt>Todd
McDevitt, PhD, a bioengineer at UCSF and the Gladstone Institutes.
It’s also possible, however, that an infected
person’s own immune system may do the majority of
the damage in the heart, as it appears to do in
the lungs. “The heart probably gets infected by a
lot of other viruses, and they don’t have a
lethal effect,” Conklin says. “What makes this one different?”
Graph with three bars. Bar at left has 80% at top
and Non-Severe at bottom. Bar in middle has 15%
at top and Severe at bottom Bar at right has 5%
at top and Critical at bottom. Text below graph
reads: Most symptomatic cases of COVID-19 are
mild. To left of graph, small circle with the
letter “i” in the middle opens to text reading:
Graph Data: Wu et al., JAMA 2020. Livingston et
al., JAMA 2020. Garg et al, MMWR 2020. Stoke et
al., MMWR 2020. Left of graph: illustration of a coronavirus.
Most symptomatic cases of COVID-19 are mild.
Emacs!
Stranger things
Toward the end of March, as San Francisco began
to warm up, Sonia got cold feet. She put on wool
socks and turned up her heater. Still, her feet
felt frozen. Three days later, her soles turned
splotchy purple. Red dots appeared on her toes.
At night, her cold feet itched and burned.
Walking hurt. And she was exhausted, napping
through afternoon Zoom meetings. “It was so
bizarre,” says Sonia, a San Francisco resident. A
week later, her symptoms were gone.
“Yes, COVID,” wrote
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/lindy.fox>Lindy Fox,
MD, a UCSF professor of dermatology, replying to
an email describing Sonia’s case. Sonia wasn’t
surprised. Anyone, like her, who’s been following
news of the pandemic has probably heard about
“COVID toes,” a painful or itchy skin rash that
sometimes pops up in young adults with otherwise
mild or asymptomatic cases of COVID-19. “It looks
like what we call pernio, or chilblains,” Fox
says, “which is a pretty common phenomenon when
somebody goes out in cold weather – they start to
get purple or pink bumps on their fingers or toes.”
Many people with rashes like Sonia’s don’t test
positive for COVID-19, Fox says, which has made
some clinicians skeptical of the connection; when
patients have both, it’s just a coincidence, they
believe. But Fox doesn’t think so. For one thing,
“the time of year is wrong,” she says. “Pernio
usually shows up in the dead of winter.” Even
more compelling, dermatologists around the world
are “getting crazy numbers of calls about it,”
Fox says. “In the last three weeks, I’ve had
somewhere between 10 and 12 patients.
Normally, I have four a year.”
Illustration of a coronavirus symbol.
20%-40% of people with COVID-19 experience
diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting before other symptoms.
And it’s not just dermatologists who are adding
their observations to COVID-19’s ever-expanding
symptom list. Gut specialists are finding that
20% to 40% of people with the disease experience
diarrhea, nausea, or vomiting before other
symptoms, says gastroenterologist
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/michael.kattah>Michael
Kattah, MD, PhD, a UCSF assistant professor. If
you swallow virus particles, he says, there’s a
good chance they will infect cells lining your
stomach, small intestine, or colon. As in the
lungs and heart, these cells are studded with vulnerable ACE2 portals.
Especially disconcerting, Kattah says, is how
long the virus seems to persist in the gut. About
50% of patients with COVID-19 have virus
particles in their stools, often for weeks after
their nose swabs test negative, he points out.
Laboratory studies show that these particles are
often still alive and can infect cells in a petri
dish. Whether fecal transmission occurs between
people, however, is an open question. If the
answer is yes, people recovering from COVID-19
may need to stay quarantined even after they feel
well, and the rest of us will need to be as
meticulous about bathroom hygiene as we’ve become
about handwashing and mask-wearing.
Other specialists are also raising flags.
Neurologists worry about reports of COVID-19
patients with headaches, “brain fog,” loss of the
sense of smell, dizziness, delirium, and, in rare
cases, stroke. Nephrologists worry about kidney
stress and failure. Hepatologists worry about
liver injuries. Ophthalmologists worry about pink
eye. Pediatricians, meanwhile, worry about a
peculiar
<https://youtu.be/ny4NivhjHAQ?t=5014>COVID-related
inflammatory syndrome that’s showing up in kids and young adults.
Researchers are still sorting out the causes for
this constellation of effects. If you come down
with a particular symptom, is it because the
virus is attacking your cells? Because your
immune system is overreacting? Or just because
you’re very sick? In any severe illness, for
example, the kidneys must work extra hard to
filter waste and control nutrients and fluid; if
overtaxed, they may begin to fail. Similarly,
cognitive problems can result from increased
blood toxins due to stressed kidneys or from low
oxygen due to respiratory distress. “There’s a
lot of smoke,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/michael.r.wilson>Michael
Wilson, MD ’07, MAS ’16, the Rachleff
Distinguished Professor at UCSF’s Weill Institute
for Neurosciences. “We need to figure out where the fire is coming from.”
Recently, there’s been speculation that some of
COVID-19’s seemingly disparate symptoms may stem
from trouble in the blood. Blood clots, for
example, are showing up in cases of COVID-19
frequently enough for clinicians to take notice.
“There’s something unique about the coagulation
system in these patients,” says nephrologist
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/kathleen.liu>Kathleen
Liu, MD ’99, PhD ’97, MAS ’07, a UCSF professor
of medicine. In caring for COVID-19 patients on
dialysis machines, she’s been surprised to see
blood clots block dialysis tubes more than usual.
Clotted tubes are common, she says, “but this is extreme.”
Illustration of a coronavirus symbol.
Evidence suggests SARS-CoV-2 can infect cells in
the walls of blood vessels that help regulate clotting.
That may be because, as growing evidence
suggests, SARS-CoV-2 can infect cells in the
walls of blood vessels that help regulate blood
flow and coagulation, or clotting. If true, this
behavior could explain some of the virus’s
weirder (and rarer) manifestations, such as heart
attacks, strokes, and even “COVID toes.”
“Our vasculature is a contiguous system,” says
cardiologist Parikh. “Thus injury in one area,
such as blood vessels in the lungs, can set off
clotting cascades that affect multiple organs.”
Some of that trouble likely results from
inflammation triggered by the immune system, she
points out, although another culprit may be the
body’s RAAS, or renin-angiotensin-aldosterone
system, a hormone system that controls blood
pressure and fluid balance. Because RAAS involves
ACE2 receptors, Parikh suspects it may become
disrupted when the virus infects cells through
these receptors, thus triggering coagulation and
other downstream effects. Her lab is now studying
this system in COVID-19 patients to better
understand how SARS-CoV-2 infection affects it.
Inevitably, some ailments may turn out to be red
herrings. During a pandemic, when people are
flocking to hospitals with infections, clinicians
will also see a rise in other health problems,
simply by the rules of statistics, points out
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/andy.josephson>S.
Andrew Josephson, MD, the Francheschi-Mitchell
Professor, chair of UCSF’s neurology department,
and a member of the Weill Institute for
Neurosciences. “If the prevalence of infection is
high, then almost any condition – a broken leg,
if you will – you might conclude is associated with COVID-19.”
“As clinicians, we want to get information to our
medical community and to the public as quickly as
possible,” Josephson says, “but we have to be
cautious about not making too big a deal of a little blip.”
The long tail
As with any infection, how long a bout of
COVID-19 lasts
<https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/The-curious-case-of-the-SF-doctor-who-s-been-15304660.php>varies
from person to person. If you’re ill enough to
need critical care, you can expect the disease to
take at least a few weeks to run its course. In
some cases, symptoms persist for months. For a
typical milder case, though, you should feel better within a couple weeks.
At that point, the question foremost on your mind
will be: Am I immune? There are now more than a
dozen antibody tests on the market, but most are
unreliable,
<https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/24/health/coronavirus-antibody-tests.html>according
to UCSF research. And even the best tests can’t
tell you whether you have enough of the right
kinds of antibodies to protect you against
reinfection. “There is a lot of hope and belief
that we’ll have an antibody test that actually
informs us of immunity, but we’re not quite there
yet,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/charles.langelier>Chaz
Langelier, MD, PhD, a UCSF assistant professor of
medicine who is working to improve diagnostic tools for COVID-19.
What we have in the meantime are a lot of
unknowns: If you do become immune to SARS-CoV-2,
when and how does that occur? Will you gain
immunity from a mild or asymptomatic case, as
well as a severe one? How long will that immunity last?
“The answers will have huge implications for
social distancing and masking and for getting the
economy back up and running,” says
<https://profiles.ucsf.edu/michael.peluso>Michael
Peluso, MD, a clinical fellow who came to UCSF
three years ago to help fight HIV. Now he’s
co-leading <https://www.liincstudy.org/>a new
study called LIINC (Long-term Impact of Infection
with Novel Coronavirus), which is enrolling
people who have been infected with SARS-CoV-2 and
will follow them for two years. Besides
illuminating changes in immunity over time, LIINC
is investigating chronic effects of infection on
the immune system, lungs, heart, brain, blood, and other parts of the body.
“I hope people will recover and immunity will be
protective and long-lasting, and that will be that,” Peluso says.
It’s what we all hope. We hope we will beat an
infection swiftly – or, better yet, avoid the
virus until there is a vaccine. We hope that if
we do fall gravely ill, we will be cared for by
the best providers and tended to by people we
love. The reality, as we already know, is more
complicated. And even if COVID-19 doesn’t batter
our bodies, the pandemic will surely leave scars
– on our psyches, our livelihoods, our
institutions, and our health – that we are only
beginning to fathom. In truth, we don’t know how
our cards will fall, as individuals or as a
people. Only time – and data – will tell.
|