The best way to tell male brewer's apart from rusty's is how shiny they are.
Male rusty is not very shiny at all, whereas brewer's is extremely glossy -
it reminds me of a miniature grackle.
And of course rusty would be much more likely in the northeast. There are a
number of rusty's moving through now. But anything is possible.
Can you post the photos?
[log in to unmask]