Print

Print


Re: Science & denial
So my question:  Can any of you think offhand of links online, or in common journals (which a university would typically have online subscriptions to) that also illustrate science that has contradicted contemporary social values -- mechanistic atomism, primacy of the individual, sanctity of the nuclear family, glories of capitalism, etc. -- but is unarguably good science?

Here's an article that surveys the available archeological evidence and critiques the claim that warfare has always been part of human society:

R. Brian Ferguson, "The Birth of War," Natural History, July/August 2003, available online at http://www.naturalhistorymag.com/0703/0703_feature.html.

The problem is that any science that contradicts contemporary social values is, ipso facto, controversial,so while it may be good science, it won't be "unarguably good science" until the values change.

Ferguson replies to his critics here: http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1134/is_8_112/ai_108551806.

--PG