The Earth Report ed. E Goldsmith, N
Hildyard. London: Mitchell Beazley 1988 p.
149
Fluoridation Technique of adding
fluorides to public water supplies, with the intention of reducing
tooth decay.
Fluoridation transformed a liability of the aluminium industry
(bulk sodium fluoride) into a commercial product. Some
fluoridation is done with fluosilicic acid, a waste from manufacture
of superphosphate fertiliser.
Tooth decay turns
out to have declined by about two-thirds since the 1950s in the
wealthy countries that gather dental statistics. This welcome
trend is not understood; possible causes may include improved diet and
brushing, widespread antibiotics secreted in saliva, and, recently,
fluoride in toothpaste, a concentrated direct application that may
well be effective. But thorough surveys have corrected the
earlier claim that natural fluoride in water is correlated with
relative freedom from tooth decay. Trials claimed to demonstrate
benefit from fluoridation have been severely criticized for lack of
controls, and other major defects.
In some
still-controversial studies, fluoridation has, on the other hand, been
rather closely correlated with cancer. Various other types of
harm have been suspected; the one established beyond dispute is dental
fluorosis - bilaterally symmetrical diffuse white mottling
of the teeth, a form of damage commonly observed among children
drinking water fluoridated to 1 ppm. The margin, if any, is
uncomfortably slim between 1 ppm and levels known to cause serious
damage to bones (skeletal fluorosis). In addition, there is the
possibility of adverse synergistic reactions between the fluoride
added to water and the thousands of other chemicals to which modern
industrial systems expose us.
[as the original author I've taken the opportunity to correct
a few editing errors - RM]