That is a fallacious statement of my argument, which is:
Topic A is important.
Study B provides useful insights into Topic A, because it identifies cultural sources of illusions about relationships.
Therefore, Study B is important or at least interesting.
Actually, I think I will use this one in my critical thinking class next semester as an exercise for the students to point out its weaknesses.
The following is a fallacious argument:
Topic A is important.
Study B is about A.
Therefore, study B is important.
--PGOn Tue, Dec 16, 2008 at 11:51 AM, Michael Balter <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
Actually, I think this kind of study is important, and I think if Phil thought about it a little bit more he might agree. Unrealistic expectations about love and marriage are indeed a key factor in relationships breaking up, as most people who have voyaged very far into adulthood know anecdotally and which psychologists, family therapists and professionals know from their practices and research. Since troubled relationships are a key cause of suffering in the world, understanding more about them makes sense to me.
As I have said before, let's not be the John McCains and Sarah Palins of the left when it comes to critiquing science.
MB--On Tue, Dec 16, 2008 at 12:43 PM, Phil Gasper <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
Published: 2008/12/16 10:02:45 GMT
Rom-coms 'spoil your love life'
Watching romantic comedies can spoil your love life, a study by a university in Edinburgh has claimed.
Rom-coms have been blamed by relationship experts at Heriot Watt University for promoting unrealistic expectations when it comes to love.
They found fans of films such as Runaway Bride and Notting Hill often fail to communicate with their partner.
Many held the view if someone is meant to be with you, then they should know what you want without you telling them.
Psychologists at the family and personal relationships laboratory at the university studied 40 top box office hits between 1995 and 2005, and identified common themes which they believed were unrealistic.
The movies included You've Got Mail, Maid In Manhattan, The Wedding Planner and While You Were Sleeping.
The university's Dr Bjarne Holmes said: "Marriage counsellors often see couples who believe that sex should always be perfect, and if someone is meant to be with you then they will know what you want without you needing to communicate it.
"We now have some emerging evidence that suggests popular media play a role in perpetuating these ideas in people's minds.
"The problem is that while most of us know that the idea of a perfect relationship is unrealistic, some of us are still more influenced by media portrayals than we realise."
As part of the project, 100 student volunteers were asked to watch the 2001 romantic comedy Serendipity, while a further 100 watched a David Lynch drama.
Students watching the romantic film were later found to be more likely to believe in fate and destiny. A further study found that fans of romantic comedies had a stronger belief in predestined love.
Kimberly Johnson, who also worked on the study, said: "Films do capture the excitement of new relationships but they also wrongly suggest that trust and committed love exist from the moment people meet, whereas these are qualities that normally take years to develop."
The researchers have now launched an online study on media and relationships.
They are asking people to participate by answering questions about personality, relationships, and media consumption habits by filling in a questionnaire which you can click on here.
Contributing Correspondent, Science
Adjunct Professor of Journalism,
Email: [log in to unmask]
Balter's Blog: michael-balter.blogspot.com