Yes, that was a terrible story. I believe the University of Johannesburg has
50000 places and nearly twice as many applicants. Young people are well
aware that even with a tertiary qualification, their chances of getting a
job are not fantastic, and they are desperate. I believe many end up doing
quite inappropriate courses - Mbali shared a room with a girl last year who
dropped out because she hated what she was studying. When I asked why she
had registered for it then, Mbali said, well, it was the only course in
which there was space. The boy whose mother died wants to do medicine, but
since there're no places, he is now doing a diploma course - the very one
Mbali was on last year, biotechnology. 

There are other mismatches, too - most kids think university is the only
option, whereas my neighbour, a soil science professor, told me of two
friends' sons who went and did plumbing and something else practical and
artisanal, and are now happily making stacks of money and starting their own

I would have hated to think that Mbali - who plainly fits science well - had
missed out to provide place for some kid who would be better off doing a
different course.


From: Science for the People Discussion List
[mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Phil Gasper
Sent: 25 January 2012 08:53 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: My private moment of joy



Congratulations to you and Mbali. On Monday I heard a story on National
Public Radio in the US that mentioned the extreme shortage of university
openings in S. Africa, and that one woman was killed in a stampede at the
University of Johannesburg at the beginning of the year after thousands of
people waited overnight to register for a very limited numbers of places
akes-online-schooling-to-the-next-academic-level). Of course the solution
that NPR was promoting was enrolling thousands of students in the same
online class in which students would have zero personal contact with the
instructor, rather than increasing funding to higher education.


On Wed, Jan 25, 2012 at 6:57 AM, Mandi Smallhorne <[log in to unmask]>

Can I share this with you?

I may have mentioned that eight years ago I met and befriended an Aids
orphan in one of our shanty towns. Mbali is very bright, and battled her way
through a very poor and dysfunctional school to qualify for university. She
wanted to do a BSc, but could not get in due to space constraints. She
therefore did a diploma course in biotechnology at the University of
Johannesburg last year - and did very well, getting three distinctions, one
in chemistry.

We applied to transfer her to BSc this year, and the admin botched things -
they told her she was accepted subject to space being available, then told
her she'd been rejected. I got into a rage and wrote an impassioned - but I
hope reasoned - email to the dean, pointing out that this way, South Africa
was likely to lose a scientist and gain a technician. She has proved that
she is dedicated and hardworking, and will not drop out mid-year, as so many
of our deeply unprepared first-years do. I said she should be accepted based
solely on her 2011 results, but added that I found it really sad that they
were turning down a girl who, on one occasion, turned to me with a glowing
face and said, "I really LOVE science!" Someone who has the potential to go
way beyond BSc, to really contribute to science nationally and globally.
(Plus, I reminded them, she has a sponsor who is paying her fees, and I am
sure I can fundraise a little to cover books - so many of our first-years
don't have enough for their fees, and can't qualify for a bank loan, the
Catch-22 being banks won't loan to first-years who they well know could drop

And guess what? I got a phone call from the faculty. They have decided to
accept Mbali. She's on her way! A kid born in a corrugated iron shack will
become a scientist, will, I am sure, one day be Dr Nkabinde. Tears,
laughter, and a desire to rush out and polka down the street.. OMG, I am so





__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature
database 6825 (20120125) __________

The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.



__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature
database 6827 (20120125) __________


The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.


__________ Information from ESET NOD32 Antivirus, version of virus signature
database 6828 (20120126) __________


The message was checked by ESET NOD32 Antivirus.