Mystery disease kills thousands in Central
Saturday, February 11, 2012 CHICHIGALPA, Nicaragua (AP)
Jesus Ignacio Flores started working when he was 16, laboring long
hours on construction sites and in the fields of his country's biggest
Three years ago his kidneys started to fail and flooded his body with
toxins. He became too weak to work, wracked by cramps, headaches and
On Jan. 19 he died on the porch of his house. He was 51. His withered
body was dressed by his weeping wife, embraced a final time, then carried
in the bed of a pickup truck to a grave on the edge of Chichigalpa, a
town in Nicaragua's sugar-growing heartland, where studies have found
more than one in four men showing symptoms of chronic kidney
A mysterious epidemic is devastating the Pacific coast of Central
America, killing more than 24,000 people in El Salvador and Nicaragua
since 2000 and striking thousands of others with chronic kidney disease
at rates unseen virtually anywhere else. Scientists say they have
received reports of the phenomenon as far north as southern Mexico and as
far south as Panama.
Last year it reached the point where El Salvador's health minister, Dr.
Maria Isabel Rodriguez, appealed for international help, saying the
epidemic was undermining health systems.
Wilfredo Ordonez, who has harvested corn, sesame and rice for more than
30 years in the Bajo Lempa region of El Salvador, was hit by the chronic
disease when he was 38. Ten years later, he depends on dialysis
treatments he administers to himself four times a day.
"This is a disease that comes with no warning, and when they find
it, it's too late," Ordonez said as he lay on a hammock on his
Many of the victims were manual laborers or worked in sugar cane fields
that cover much of the coastal lowlands. Patients, local doctors and
activists say they believe the culprit lurks among the agricultural
chemicals workers have used for years with virtually none of the
protections required in more developed countries. But a growing body of
evidence supports a more complicated and counterintuitive
The roots of the epidemic, scientists say, appear to lie in the grueling
nature of the work performed by its victims, including construction
workers, miners and others who labor hour after hour without enough water
in blazing temperatures, pushing their bodies through repeated bouts of
extreme dehydration and heat stress for years on end. Many start as young
as 10. The punishing routine appears to be a key part of some previously
unknown trigger of chronic kidney disease, which is normally caused by
diabetes and high-blood pressure, maladies absent in most of the patients
in Central America.
"The thing that evidence most strongly points to is this idea of
manual labor and not enough hydration," said
Daniel Brooks, a professor of epidemiology at
School of Public Health, who has worked on a series of studies of the
kidney disease epidemic.
Because hard work and intense heat alone are hardly a phenomenon unique
to Central America, some researchers will not rule out manmade factors.
But no strong evidence has turned up.
"I think that everything points away from pesticides," said Dr.
Catharina Wesseling, an occupational and environmental epidemiologist who
also is regional director of the Program on Work, Health and Environment
in Central America. "It is too multinational; it is too spread
"I would place my bet on repeated dehydration, acute attacks
everyday. That is my bet, my guess, but nothing is proved."
Richard J. Johnson, a kidney specialist at the
University of Colorado, Denver, is working with other researchers
investigating the cause of the disease. They too suspect chronic
"This is a new concept, but there's some evidence supporting
it," Johnson said. "There are other ways to damage the kidney.
Heavy metals, chemicals, toxins have all been considered, but to date
there have been no leading candidates to explain what's going on in
"As these possibilities get exhausted, recurrent dehydration is
moving up on the list."
In Nicaragua, the number of annual deaths from chronic kidney disease
more than doubled in a decade, from 466 in 2000 to 1,047 in 2010,
according to the
Pan American Health Organization, a regional arm of the World Health
Organization. In El Salvador, the agency reported a similar jump, from
1,282 in 2000 to 2,181 in 2010.
Farther down the coast, in the cane-growing lowlands of northern Costa
Rica, there also have been sharp increases in kidney disease, Wesseling
said, and the Pan American body's statistics show deaths are on the rise
in Panama, although at less dramatic rates.
While some of the rising numbers may be due to better record-keeping,
scientists have no doubt they are facing something deadly and previously
unknown to medicine.
In nations with more developed health systems, the disease that impairs
the kidney's ability to cleanse the blood is diagnosed relatively early
and treated with dialysis in medical clinics. In Central America, many of
the victims treat themselves at home with a cheaper but less efficient
form of dialysis, or go without any dialysis at all.
At a hospital in the Nicaraguan town of Chinandega, Segundo Zapata
Palacios sat motionless in his room, bent over with his head on the
"He no longer wants to talk," said his wife,
His levels of creatinine, a chemical marker of kidney failure, were 25
times the normal amount.
His family told him he was being hospitalized to receive dialysis. In
reality, the hope was to ease his pain before his inevitable death, said
Carmen Rios, a leader of Nicaragua's Association of Chronic Kidney
Disease Patients, a support and advocacy group.
"There's already nothing to do," she said. "He was
hospitalized on Jan. 23 just waiting to die."
Zapata Palacios passed away on Jan. 26. He was 49.
Working with scientists from Costa Rica, El Salvador and Nicaragua,
Wesseling tested groups on the coast and compared them with groups who
had similar work habits and exposure to pesticide but lived and worked
more than 500 meters (1,500 feet) above sea level.
Some 30 percent of coastal dwellers had elevated levels of creatinine,
strongly suggesting environment rather than agrochemicals was to blame,
Brooks, the epidemiologist, said. The study is expected to be published
in a peer-reviewed journal in coming weeks.
Brooks and Johnson, the kidney specialist, said they have seen echoes of
the Central American phenomenon in reports from hot farming areas in Sri
Lanka, Egypt and the Indian east coast.
"We don't really know how widespread this is," Brooks said.
"This may be an under-recognized epidemic."
Jason Glaser, co-founder of a group working to help victims of the
epidemic in Nicaragua, said he and colleagues also have begun receiving
reports of mysterious kidney disease among sugar cane workers in
Despite the growing consensus among international experts,
Elsy Brizuela, a doctor who works with an
El Salvadoran project to treat workers and research the epidemic,
discounts the dehydration theory and insists "the common factor is
exposure to herbicides and poisons."
Nicaragua's highest rates of chronic kidney disease show up around the
Ingenio San Antonio, a plant owned by the
Pellas Group conglomerate, whose sugar mill processes nearly half the
nation's sugar. Flores and Zapata Palacios both worked at the
According to one of Brooks' studies, about eight years ago the factory
started providing electrolyte solution and protein cookies to workers who
previously brought their own water to work. But the study also found that
some workers were cutting sugar cane for as long as 9 1/2 hours a day
with virtually no break and little shade in average temperatures of 30 C
In 2006, the plantation, owned by one of the country's richest families,
received $36.5 million in loans from the
International Finance Corp., the private-sector arm of the World Bank
Group, to buy more land, expand its processing plant and produce more
sugar for consumers and ethanol production.
In a statement, the IFC said it had examined the social and environmental
impacts of its loans as part of a due diligence process and did not
identify kidney disease as something related to the sugar plantation's
Nonetheless, the statement said, "we are concerned about this
disease that affects not only Nicaragua but other countries in the
region, and will follow closely any new findings."
Ariel Granera, a spokesman for the Pellas' business conglomerate, said
that starting as early as 1993 the company had begun taking a wide
variety of precautions to avoid heat stress in its workers, from starting
their shifts very early in the morning to providing them with many
gallons of drinking water per day.
Associated Press reporters saw workers bringing water bottles from their
homes, which they refilled during the day from large cylinders of water
in the buses that bring them to the fields.
Glaser, the co-founder of the activist group in Nicaragua, La Isla
Foundation, said that nonetheless many worker protections in the region
are badly enforced by the companies and government regulators,
particularly measures to stop workers with failing kidneys from working
in the cane fields owned by the Pellas Group and other
Many workers disqualified by tests showing high levels of creatinine go
back to work in the fields for subcontractors with less stringent
standards, he said. Some use false IDs, or give their IDs to their
healthy sons, who then pass the tests and go work in the cane fields,
damaging their kidneys.
"This is the only job in town," Glaser said. "It's all
they're trained to do. It's all they know."
The Ingenio San Antonio mill processes cane from more than 24,000
hectares (60,000 acres) of fields, about half directly owned by the mill
and most of the rest by independent farmers.
The trade group for Nicaragua's sugar companies said the Boston
University study had confirmed that "the agricultural sugar industry
in Nicaragua has no responsibility whatsoever for chronic renal
insufficiency in Nicaragua" because the research found that "in
the current body of scientific knowledge there is no way to establish a
direct link between sugar cane cultivation and renal
Brooks, the epidemiologist at Boston University, told the AP that the
study simply said there was no definitive scientific proof of the cause,
but that all possible connections remained open to future
In comparison with Nicaragua, where thousands of kidney disease sufferers
work for large sugar estates, in El Salvador many of them are independent
small farmers. They blame agricultural chemicals and few appear to have
significantly changed their work habits in response to the latest
research, which has not received significant publicity in El
In Nicaragua, the dangers are better known, but still, workers need jobs.
Zapata Palacios left eight children. Three of them work in the cane
Two already show signs of disease.
Associated Press writer Filadelfo Aleman reported this story in
Chichigalpa, Nicaragua, and Michael Weissenstein reported from Mexico
City. AP writers Marcos Aleman in Bajo Lempa, El Salvador, and Romina
Ruiz-Goiriena in Guatemala City contributed to this report.
My bet is that the diseases are caused by microorganisms in the
fertilizers being used. I wonder if the same diseases are occurring on
organic and fertilizer-free farms. It's simply amazing that some
"scientists" are blaming this on workers' lifestyles (not
drinking enough water) as though not until recently did sugar cane
workers labor under severe conditions stressing the body. It's probably
not that they're not drinking sufficient water, but it's worth looking at
what's in the water that they are drinking.
- Mitchel Cohen