December 8, 2016
Militant nonviolent resistance works.
- “You gotta remember,
establishment, it’s just a name for evil. The monster doesn’t care
whether it kills all the students or whether there’s a revolution. It’s
not thinking logically, it’s out of control.”
- John Lennon (1969)
Peaceful, prolonged protests work.
Mass movements with huge numbers of participants work.
Yes, America, it is possible to use occupations and civil disobedience to
oppose government policies, counter injustice and bring about change
outside the confines of the ballot box.
It has been done before. It is being done now. It can be done
For example, in May of 1932, more than 43,000 people, dubbed the Bonus
ArmyWorld War I veterans and their familiesmarched on Washington. Out
of work, destitute and with families to feed, more than 10,000 veterans
set up tent cities in the nation’s capital and refused to leave until the
government agreed to pay the bonuses they had been promised as a reward
for their services.
The Senate voted against paying them immediately, but the protesters
didn’t budge. Congress adjourned for the summer, and still the protesters
remained encamped. Finally, on July 28, under orders from President
Herbert Hoover, the military descended with tanks and cavalry and drove
the protesters out, setting their makeshift camps on fire. Still, the
protesters returned the following year, and eventually their efforts not
only succeeded in securing payment of the bonuses but contributed to the
passage of the G.I. Bill of Rights.
Similarly, the Civil Rights Movement mobilized hundreds of thousands of
people to strike at the core of an unjust and discriminatory society.
Likewise, while the 1960s anti-war movement began with a few thousand
perceived radicals, it ended with hundreds of thousands of protesters,
spanning all walks of life, demanding the end of American military
Most recently, after months of protests over the construction of a
pipeline that members of the Sioux tribe insisted would harm their water
the Army Corp of Engineers has agreed to look for an alternate route for
the Dakota Access Pipeline to cross under Lake Oahe in North
This kind of “power to the people” activismgrassroots, populist and
potentis exactly the brand of civic engagement John Lennon advocated
throughout his career as a musician and anti-war activist.
It’s been 36 years since Lennon was
gunned down by an assassin’s bullet on December 8, 1980, but his
legacy and the lessons he imparted in his music and his activism have not
diminished over the years.
All of the many complaints we have about government todaysurveillance,
militarism, corruption, harassment, SWAT team raids, political
persecution, spying, overcriminalization, etc.were present in Lennon’s
day and formed the basis of his call for social justice, peace and a
Little wonder, then, that the U.S. government saw him as enemy number
Because he never refrained from speaking truth to power, Lennon became a
prime example of the lengths to which the U.S. government will go to
persecute those who dare to challenge its authority.
Lennon was the subject of a four-year campaign of surveillance and
harassment by the U.S. government (spearheaded by FBI Director J. Edgar
Hoover), an attempt by President Richard Nixon to have him “neutralized”
and deported. As Adam Cohen of the New York Times points out, “The
F.B.I.’s surveillance of Lennon is a reminder of how easily
spying can become unmoored from any legitimate law enforcement
purpose. What is more surprising, and ultimately more unsettling, is
the degree to which the surveillance turns out to have been intertwined
with electoral politics.”
Years after Lennon’s assassination, it would be revealed that the FBI had
collected 281 pages of
surveillance files on him. As the New York Times
, “Critics of today’s domestic surveillance object largely on privacy
grounds. They have focused far less on how easily government surveillance
can become an instrument for the people in power to try to hold on to
power. ‘The U.S. vs. John Lennon’ … is the story not only of one man
being harassed, but of a democracy being undermined.”
Such government-directed harassment was nothing new.
The FBI has had a long history of persecuting, prosecuting and generally
harassing activists, politicians, and cultural figures, most notably
among the latter such
celebrated names as folk singer Pete Seeger, painter Pablo Picasso,
comic actor and filmmaker Charlie Chaplin, comedian Lenny Bruce and poet
Allen Ginsberg. Among those most closely watched by the FBI was Martin
Luther King Jr., a man labeled by the FBI as “the most dangerous and
effective Negro leader in the country.”
In Lennon’s case, the ex-Beatle had learned early on that rock music
could serve a political end by proclaiming a radical message. More
importantly, Lennon saw that his music could mobilize the public and help
to bring about change.
For instance, in 1971 at a concert in Ann Arbor, Mich., Lennon took to
the stage and in his usual confrontational style belted out “John
Sinclair,” a song he had written about a man sentenced to
in prison for possessing two marijuana cigarettes. Within days of
Lennon’s call for action, the Michigan Supreme Court ordered Sinclair
While Lennon believed in the power of the people, he also understood the
danger of a power-hungry government. “The trouble with government as it
is, is that it doesn’t represent the people,” observed Lennon.
It controls them.”
By March 1971, when his “Power to the People” single was released, it was
clear where Lennon stood. Having moved to New York City that same year,
Lennon was ready to participate in political activism against the U. S.
government, the “monster” that was financing the war in Vietnam.
The release of Lennon’s Sometime in New York City album, which
contained a radical anti-government message in virtually every song and
depicted President Richard Nixon and Chinese Chairman Mao Tse-tung
dancing together nude on the cover, only fanned the flames of the
conflict to come.
However, the official U.S. war against Lennon began in earnest in 1972
after rumors surfaced that Lennon planned to embark on a U.S. concert
tour that would combine rock music with antiwar organizing and voter
registration. Nixon, fearing Lennon’s influence on about 11 million new
voters (1972 was the first year that 18-year-olds could vote), had the
ex-Beatle served with deportation orders “in an
effort to silence him as a voice of the peace movement.”
As Lennon’s FBI file shows, memos and reports about the FBI’s
surveillance of the anti-war activist had been flying back and forth
between Hoover, the Nixon White House, various senators, the FBI and the
U.S. Immigration Office.
Nixon’s pursuit of Lennon was relentless and misplaced.
Despite the fact that Lennon was not plotting to bring down the Nixon
Administration, as the government feared, the government persisted in its
efforts to have him deported. Equally determined to resist, Lennon dug in
and fought back. Every time he was ordered out of the country, his
lawyers delayed the process by filing an appeal.
Finally, in 1976, Lennon won the battle to stay in the country and by
1980, he had re-emerged with a new album and plans to become politically
active again. The old radical was back and ready to cause
Unfortunately, Lennon’s time as a troublemaker was short-lived.
Mark David Chapman was waiting in the shadows on Dec. 8, 1980, just
as Lennon was returning to his New York apartment building.
As Lennon stepped outside the car to greet the fans congregating outside,
Chapman, in an eerie echo of the FBI’s moniker for Lennon, called out,
Lennon turned and was met with a barrage of gunfire as Chapmandropping
into a two-handed combat stanceemptied his .38-caliber pistol and pumped
four hollow-point bullets into his back and left arm. Lennon stumbled,
staggered forward and, with blood pouring from his mouth and chest,
collapsed to the ground.
John Lennon was pronounced dead on arrival at the hospital.
Much like Martin Luther King Jr., John F. Kennedy, Malcolm X, Robert
Kennedy and others who have died attempting to challenge the
powers-that-be, Lennon had finally been “neutralized.”
Still, you can’t murder a movement with a bullet and a madman: Lennon’s
legacy lives on in his words, his music and his efforts to speak truth to
As Yoko Ono shared in a 2014 letter to the parole board tasked with
determining whether Chapman should be released: “A man of humble origin,
[John Lennon] brought light and hope to the whole world with his words
and music. He tried to be a
good power for the world, and he was. He gave encouragement,
inspiration and dreams to people regardless of their race, creed and
Lennon’s work to change the world for the better is far from
Peace remains out of reach. Activism and whistleblowers continue to be
prosecuted for challenging the government’s authority. Militarism is on
the rise, all the while the governmental war machine continues to wreak
havoc on innocent lives.
For those of us who joined with John Lennon to imagine a world of peace,
it’s getting harder to reconcile that dream with the reality of the
American police state. And as I point out in my book
Battlefield America: The War on the American People, those who do
dare to speak up are labeled dissidents, troublemakers, terrorists,
lunatics, or mentally ill and tagged for surveillance, censorship or,
worse, involuntary detention.
As Lennon shared in a 1968 interview:
So what’s the answer?
- I think all our society is run by insane people for insane
objectives… I think we’re being run by maniacs for maniacal means. If
anybody can put on paper what our government and the American government
and the Russian… Chinese… what they are actually trying to do, and what
they think they’re doing, I’d be very pleased to know what they think
they’re doing. I think they’re all insane. But
I’m liable to be put away as insane for expressing that. That’s
what’s insane about it.”
Lennon had a multitude of suggestions.
“If everyone demanded peace instead of another television set, then
there’d be peace.”
“Produce your own dream. If you want to save Peru, go save Peru. It’s
quite possible to do anything, but not to put it on the leaders….You have
to do it yourself.”
“Peace is not something you wish for; It’s something you make, Something
you do, Something you are, And something you give away.”
“If you want peace, you won’t get it with violence.”
“Say you want a revolution / We better get on right away / Well you get
on your feet / And out on the street / Singing power to the
And my favorite advice of all: “All you need is love. Love is all you
John W. Whitehead is the president of The Rutherford Institute and
Battlefield America: The War on the American People.