We have made the switch, but we have done it in stages and with a plan.  There has been some push-back, but not nearly as one would expect.  Off the top of my head, we are probably at 50-60% faculty using Chromebooks.  First, we started this last year with the Acer Chromebook 14 for Work and this year we went with the HP Chromebook 13 G1.  Both have 8GB RAM and are significantly "nicer" than student Chromebooks.  Now, for the groups/plan:

Group A) Teachers that want to switch right away, they swap their Mac/Win for a teacher Chromebook, no questions asked.
Group B) Teachers that want to test-drive a teacher Chromebook but don't want to give back their Mac/Win laptop until the end of the school year.
Group C) Teachers that want never want a Chromebook under any circumstance, they want to retire with their Mac/Win laptop. That's fine, they can keep it, but they will never get an upgrade. They can move to Group B or A anytime.
Group D) New teachers automatically get a teacher Chromebook.

Now, some parts of the success we have had with this plan is that 1) we eat our own dog food - I, and our IT staff, have been using a Chromebook exclusively for at least 4-5 years (before we even thought about bringing this to teachers), so the whole "If I can do it, you can do it" lends some weight. And 2) Administrators are in the exact same boat.  And right now, probably half of our Admin team including new principals and our Superintendent are using Chromebooks.  Finally, the fact that we aren't mandating a forced switch for everyone (Group C) has helped some of the heartburn.  Change is difficult, but it can be done.

Hope that helps,


On Thu, Dec 14, 2017 at 8:27 AM Keith Puffer <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

No discussion regarding ergonomics, however, I agree with you that if a device is going to be used for extended time each day, then user habits as well as device layout could be looked at.  (As someone who has had the responsibility in previous employment to look at ergonomics, I think this is something that has had very little address in the Educational realm - perhaps I just have not been listening for that conversation and optimistically oblivious to the subject.)  Keyboard size, distance of the keyboard from front edge of device, screen size...all factors in ergonomics, and more so is HOW the user interacts with the device, especially for extended periods of time.

Students in the schools I support use the CTL NL6 series Chromebook and it looks like we will be moving to the J5 for Staff.  I am, again, optimistic that the flip/touch Chromebook fits both Staff and Student needs in the Chrome and Android markets (keyboarded and tablet dual functionality)...we shall see.  My opinion is that we (Staff) should use as similar device as possible to what Students use.  Granted, the OS and most functionality doesn't change greatly between Chromebook models.  Both are 11.6" screen models.

As with any device choice, the user's needs (and habits?) should be part of the discussion before purchase.

I look forward to others' comments on this thread.


On Wed, Dec 13, 2017 at 4:35 PM, Lucie deLaBruere <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
Keith you mentioned that you were switching from Mac to Chromebooks for educators..

I'm curious if there is a difference between the teacher/student device on the teacher device.  And has anyone tried a Pixel or other high end Chromebook.  Are they worth it? 

  The reason I ask is that while I was working directly with students I wanted to make sure that my device was the same as theirs so I would know what their issues are and be able to support them. 

Ergonomics has always been important to me, but even more so since my work now has a different focus and I spend long hours on my computer supporting my online students.  I was having some issues with wrist, shoulder, arm pain - that went away after I started I switched from a cheaper machine or Chromebook to a Mac.  

Since I live in the cloud,  I think I could use a Chromebook as my main device if it had a keyboard /tract pad and display that were ergonomically designed to meet the long hours I spend on a computer.   I find that the cheap Chromebook I have as my secondary device is challenging for long spells on the computer. 

Just curious if anyone has experience with a Chromebook that has been designed with ergonomics in mind.    Any recommendations welcomed! 


Lucie deLaBruere

Google Voice (802) 557 0013

[log in to unmask]

Nothing is really work unless you would rather be doing something else.
  - James M. Barrie
Google Certified Educator / Google for Education Certified Trainer, Raspberry Pi Certified Educator


Search the SCHOOL-IT Archive

Manage your Subscription to SCHOOL-IT

Keith Puffer
Technology Coordinator
Harwood Unified Union School District
340 Mad River Park, Suite 7
Waitsfield, VT 05673
Fax: 802-496-6515


Search the SCHOOL-IT Archive

Manage your Subscription to SCHOOL-IT


Larry Dougher
Windsor Southeast SU


Search the SCHOOL-IT Archive

Manage your Subscription to SCHOOL-IT